On the second site I built, I started to look around for a good commenting system again. I tried them all out again, and found myself with the last option once more: yvComment.
For a moment, I almost decided to buy a commercial product and test it, but I decided to give yvComment one more go-round, as it had been updated within the last week. I'm glad I tried it again.
The latest incarnation of yvComment shook out what I perceived as the software's flaws, and it is now rock solid and beautiful. You have a good selection of templates, the comments do not appear as articles, and there's a new management section back-end.
I love it! Great work, Yuri!