Sorry my bad English, I want to share my feel about this two software. JPayplan is good too, keep good work!
I would like to say that PayPlans in term of use, is NOT DIFFICULT, in contrast to other membership extension with same set-of-features.
We put a lot of efforts to make it easier for beginners.
#1: PayPlans, at installation is MINIMAL, i.e. DOES NOT install all feasible apps.
#2: We don't enforce any configuration. You can build plans, and sell them via payment gateways.
#3: We provide a setup-checklist, which helps you in right direction to setup the website.
#4: All of advance features are only enabled by configuration or relevant plugins. So if your use case is simple, then basic installation is sufficient for you.
#5: If you need more features or specific use-case, we have lots of apps [currently 87, http://www.jpayplans.com/app-ville.html]
At last bu not least, Thanks a lot for writing a review for PayPlans, we appreciate it.
Happy PayPlanning !