tomsel
Results 1 - 2 of 2
bytomsel, November 5, 2011
Functionality wise I find it hard to fault it. There's a few simple things I think it's missing (such as the ability to link to an external icon, adding a photo gallery to an event without using Flickr, for example), but on the whole it pretty much does what you'd expect.
Where I found it disappointing was in the front end layout. It uses layout-breaking tables for front end submission, with a huge number of poorly organised fields that to a non-technical end user looks very daunting.
Thankfully, it supports template overrides, so I was able to customise both the front end display and front end submission forms to use CSS based layouts and generally look a lot more user-friendly, without core hacks, in no time at all. It makes me wonder why this wasn't included in the first place?
For me this wasn't a huge issue, however without any technical knowledge I would have found the component useless because of these simple layout issues.
On a free component, this would be fine. On one that costs ~£40, I don't think it quite cuts it when there are other components in this price bracket that offer a much better experience on the whole.
Overall, still a good component, but let down by the simple stuff.
Where I found it disappointing was in the front end layout. It uses layout-breaking tables for front end submission, with a huge number of poorly organised fields that to a non-technical end user looks very daunting.
Thankfully, it supports template overrides, so I was able to customise both the front end display and front end submission forms to use CSS based layouts and generally look a lot more user-friendly, without core hacks, in no time at all. It makes me wonder why this wasn't included in the first place?
For me this wasn't a huge issue, however without any technical knowledge I would have found the component useless because of these simple layout issues.
On a free component, this would be fine. On one that costs ~£40, I don't think it quite cuts it when there are other components in this price bracket that offer a much better experience on the whole.
Overall, still a good component, but let down by the simple stuff.
bytomsel, November 4, 2011
This is the first time I've been impressed enough by a component to be compelled to write a review for it.
I wish every commercial extension could be this slick. The few minor issues I have had (almost all caused by myself) were solved by the support staff who replied very quickly.
Honestly can't fault the component, the support, anything. Fantastic.
I wish every commercial extension could be this slick. The few minor issues I have had (almost all caused by myself) were solved by the support staff who replied very quickly.
Honestly can't fault the component, the support, anything. Fantastic.


